Skip to content

Why I’m Not Crazy For “Silver Linings Playbook”

November 21, 2012

Writer-director Paul Schrader once said that his ill-fated 1986 rock-and-roll drama Light of Day—starring then-teen idol Michael J. Fox and Joan Jett (in a role once meant for Bruce Springsteen) as blue-collar siblings—died in the casting stage. Well, Silver Linings Playbook died in the recasting stage, when Mark Wahlberg, who’d previously worked magic with writer-director David O. Russell in Three Kings and The Fighter (not to mention I Heart Huckabee’s), was unceremoniously replaced by the allegedly cheaper Bradley Cooper in the tricky lead role of a bipolar ex-mental patient struggling to keep it together.

Well, Russell got what he paid for: Cooper’s okay, but a better actor—like, say, Mark Wahlberg (the only cast member nominated for an Oscar for Martin Scorsese’s The Departed, mind you, and he should’ve gotten recognized for Boogie Nights and The Fighter, too)—could’ve done so much more with the role. Still, that won’t stop 800 lb. gorilla Harvey Weinstein from mounting what’s no doubt destined to be a successful campaign to get Cooper a Best Actor Oscar nomination. When you really look at the film, though, whatever angst emanates from Cooper’s character, and it’s nowhere near the real pain a truly bipolar individual experiences, is generated from Russell’s skillful editing and use of music (no one employs pop music better, save maybe Martin Scorsese).

It’s a shame, because the rest of Silver Linings Playbook is sterling, finding real emotional depth in an essentially sugarcoated script. The cast received an upgrade when Jennifer Lawrence replaced Anne Hathaway in the female lead, as a cop’s promiscuous widow who cajoles Cooper into entering a dance contest. Robert De Niro wakes up from his decade-long career nap to deliver a lively turn as his Philadelphia Eagles-obsessed father, and Animal Kingdom‘s Oscar-nominated Jacki Weaver perfectly embodies his brassy wife. Most surprising of all, Chris Tucker—in his first non-Rush Hour gig of the millennium—brings a genuinely manic energy to the role of Cooper’s fellow-patient pal.

Cooper’s performance remains stubbornly on the surface, however. There’s a reason why he was cast in the reboot of The A-Team as Face, because that’s just about all he’s got going for him. Sorry, Marky Mark—your long-overdue Oscar will have to wait.

Will Silver Linings Playbook win Oscar gold for Bradley Cooper? Post a comment!

From → Posts

  1. Solara permalink

    With great respect that there was disappointment for Wahlberg supporters that this role was not his, Bradley Cooper gave this role just the right sense of a person trapped in a condition he understands so little about. Cooper’s Pat stays loving and vulnerable, he draws the audience in so we want to see his journey through. As I have had much exposure to bi-polar people, the intense scenes do not faze me but they came close for others but Pat’s openess pulls them back in. I think both these actors have a special appreciation of life and integrity, Cooper and Wahlberg. I’m looking at the Wahlberg movies I missed because of his connection to David O. Russell and SLP in particular. As to Bradley Cooper, I’m just one women amongst so many who love him for the very reason that he is NOT “just a face.”

Trackbacks & Pingbacks

  1. Will “Lincoln” Win the Oscar Vote? « Fretts on Film
  2. Oscar Math: “Zero Dark Thirty” vs. “Life of Pi” « Fretts on Film
  3. Best Actress: Dark Horses From Down Under « Fretts on Film
  4. Best Actress: Dark Horses From Down Under « Fretts on Film
  5. 10 for ’13: The New Year’s Most Exciting Movies « Fretts on Film
  6. My Fearless Oscar Nomination Predictions « Fretts on Film
  7. John Hawkes: America’s Best Actor? « Fretts on Film
  8. Should You Spend V-Day with J-Law? « Fretts on Film
  9. My Fearless Oscar Predictions 2013 « Fretts on Film
  10. Can Ryan Phillippe “Reclaim” His Career? | Fretts on Film

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: